Meet the Team

Serving businesses and families in the Tri-State for nearly two decades, the Kincaid team is here to help you with all of your personal and commercial insurance needs. To serve your needs, we’ve assembled a top-tier team of agents, servicing staff, and claims support. We’re here to help you. Request a call from one of our agents.

  • Dan Kincaid

    Dan Kincaid

    President

    Dan is the founder and President of Kincaid Insurance. For over two decades, Dan has led the company to become one of the most well-known independent agencies in Southern Indiana.

  • Jon Kincaid

    Jonathon Kincaid

    Vice President

    Jon has been with the company for over 15 years. His main focus is new and existing client relations and operations of the business. Outside of work, Jon enjoys spending time with his wife and 2 sons. He is actively involved in the Santa Claus community.

  • Jeremy Kincaid

    Jeremy Kincaid

    Vice President

    Jeremy has been with the agency for over 5 years and oversees all of the marketing and operations of the business. Outside of work, Jeremy enjoys spending time with his wife and leading an active outdoor lifestyle.

  • Melissa Middleton

    Melissa Middleton

    Life and Health Insurance Manager

    Melissa has been with the company for over 5 years and manages the benefits department, including life, health, vision, dental, and short-term and long-term disability insurance. Outside of work, Melissa enjoys photography, spending time with family, local sporting events, and being involved with local schools.

  • Donna Chapman

    Donna Chapman

    Accounting Manager

    Donna has been with the company for almost 20 years. She oversees accounting and claims in the office. Outside of work, Donna enjoys spending time with family and friends, woodworking, and being involved in the local volunteer fire department. She is a licensed Emergency Medical Responder.

  • Jeanette Lambert

    Jeanette Lambert

    Commercial Auto Underwriting Manager

    Jeanette has been with the agency for over 5 years and in the insurance industry for almost 30 years. Outside of work, Jeanette enjoys spending time with family, her dogs, crafting, and interior decorating

  • Jennifer Smith

    Jennifer Smith

    Trucking Service Agent

    Jennifer has been with the agency for almost 10 years. She is a CSR for the transportation department. Outside of work, Jennifer enjoys spending time with family and friends, reading, crafting, and listening to music.

  • Allison Hayse

    Allison Hayse

    Personal Lines CSR

    Allison recently joined the Kincaid team and handles marketing of all personal lines accounts. Outside of work, she enjoys landscaping, agricultural work, and being outdoors.

  • Anne Decker

    Anne Decker

    Commercial Lines CSR

    Anne has been with the company for over 5 years. She works primarily as a CSR for commercial insurance accounts. Outside of work, Anne is highly involved in her community and loves to spend time with her family.

  • Misty Parker

    Misty Parker

    Commercial Lines CSR

    Misty has been with the agency for almost 10 years. Misty is a CSR for commercial lines accounts. Outside of work, Misty enjoys working on her family farm, spending time with family and friends, and being outdoors.

  • Steve Libertore

    Steve Libertore

    Transportation Risk Manager

    Steve has more than 30 years specializing in trucking insurance. During this time he has successfully worked as a partner with carriers helping lower their exposure and liability while increasing their coverage.